6) Psychology
Overtrading
Buy-sell, buy-sell, buy-sell. You make 10-15 trades in a single day. It feels productive, but when you check your portfolio at month's end it's in the red? Congratulations, you might have overtrading syndrome — and it's more common than you think.
Definition
Overtrading is the habit of executing trades too frequently without strong justification, usually driven by emotion (boredom, greed, or wanting to 'recover' losses). Overtrading erodes profit through transaction costs and increasingly poor decisions from decision fatigue.
Simple Explanation (Analogy)
Ever played a video game until late at night? At 8 PM you're sharp, reflexes crisp, decisions fast. By 11 PM? You start misclicking, decision-making drops. At 2 AM? Just clicking randomly, no longer caring. Overtrading is the same — the more trades you make, the more tired your brain gets, the worse your decisions become. Except in games you only lose ranking; in stocks you lose real money.
Indonesian Stock Example
Say you're day-trading ANTM. Morning buy at Rp1,800, up to Rp1,825 you sell (Rp25 profit). Buy again at Rp1,815, it drops so you sell at Rp1,810 (Rp5 loss). Buy again... and so on. By end of day, your total profit might be Rp30/lot but broker fees eat Rp20/lot. Not to mention the time and mental energy wasted. Compare that to an investor who buys BBCA once and holds for months.
How to Use
- Set a maximum number of trades per day. For example, max 3 trades. Once you hit 3, close the trading app. Period.
- Log every trade and its reason. If the reason is 'bored' or 'just felt like it', that's a red flag. Only trade when there's a clear setup matching your trading plan.
- Calculate your total monthly transaction costs. You'll likely be shocked at how much it is. A 0.15% buy fee + 0.25% sell fee looks small, but across 20 trades a day, that can be millions of rupiah per month.
Common Mistakes
- Assuming more trades = more profits. Each trade has a cost, and the more trades you make, the higher the chance of mistakes.
- Trading out of boredom, not because of opportunity. The market doesn't owe you an opportunity every day — sometimes the best trade is no trade.
- Revenge trading: immediately buying another stock after a loss to 'recover', without analysis, ending in compounded losses.
FAQ
What's the ideal number of trades per day?
There's no exact number, but for beginners, 1-3 trades per day is more than enough. Many professional traders only take 1-2 best setups per day. Quality matters more than quantity. Warren Buffett even said investors should ideally have only 20 'buy tickets' for their entire lifetime.
How do I stop overtrading?
First, admit you're overtrading (many are in denial). Second, set hard rules: max 3 trades per day, and a checklist must be met before buying. Third, find other activities during market hours so you're not constantly tempted to open the trading app. Exercise, read, or focus on other work.